Thanks to a helpful person near the Albero Gatcha Festival machine (Thank you again, Elektra Pleides!), I was able to get both Cheap Makeup sets at last!
I took them home and put my camera right on my face so I could admire each one up close. But as I started to try them on, I was a little disappointed. They all seemed to look exactly the same. Then I backed my camera up and realized that they were boxed and I was just wearing box after box on my hand.
Pro Tip: Tattoo makeups (and, really, most SL things) are best worn after unpacking them from their boxes. *bangs forehead onto desk*